A science teacher once told me that no matter what planet we
went to, no matter how far or close it was to us, it would have the same
elements we have. Stories are very much like planets—you have the outer layer
of the story, which can be very deep, followed by several slightly deeper
pieces that you discover with time, and finally the very center that very few
people truly understand but is the true force of the book.
In this analogy, the planets ‘skeletons’ are the backbones
of the story (everything that makes it interesting and well-written) while the
life on the planet is the actual story. Stories are unique, even if they’re
based off another one—like Dorothy Must
Die being based off The Wizard of Oz.
When it comes to the basis of stories, they’re all the same, but they have
different forms of life on them. (Think of it this way: the core, inner layers,
and outer layer of the planet are the skeleton and will mostly be the same.
There may be an extra inner layer here or there, but for the most part, the basic
structure of a planet must remain the same. However, the outside of a planet
could be a thousand different things—it could look like our planet, or be
gaseous, or have entirely different vegetation, or be entirely underwater. The
appearance of the planet is where things are different, unique.)
So, with this information in mind, do writing and telling
belong in one world? Yes and no. Writing a story is nothing like telling a
story. Writing is complicated; it’s a longer process that is relatively the same
despite whatever is being told. The telling of a story is too complicated to be
just one world, though—imagine trying to live on a planet that has different
parts of it from Earth, Mars, Jupiter, and so on. Not only is that actually
impossible, but it’s also confusing and conflicting. However, understanding
what makes up a planet helps understand the story further and therefore enjoy
it more. Of course the same goes for stories: understanding what is in the
story and why will help deepen the story and make it more interesting.
In short, writing and telling don’t belong to the same story
because of their difference in what makes them up. But, despite their
differences, understanding one will lead to a benefit of the other.
What a wonderful analogy! Stories can be compared to planets. I always thought of writing as just telling on paper. You make valid points of how the two are different.
ReplyDelete